Finding the right candidates isn’t getting any easier, especially with the current demand for specialized talent in fields like tech and healthcare. According to LinkedIn, 69% of employers say that they are struggling to find qualified candidates for open positions. That’s where talent sourcing steps in. But what exactly is talent sourcing? Unlike traditional recruiting, which is focused on the interview and hiring process, talent sourcing is all about proactively finding candidates—even those who aren’t actively applying for jobs. Sourcers dive deep into candidate platforms and increasingly, they’re turning to AI recruitment tools to make the process faster and smarter.
As AI talent sourcing becomes more common, it’s clear that hiring a dedicated talent sourcer can give companies a real edge in today’s competitive landscape. But is it right for your team? In this article, we’ll dive into the pros and cons of hiring a talent sourcer in 2024.
A talent sourcer is like the talent scout for your hiring team. While recruiters often focus on the entire hiring process, a talent sourcer’s job is to find potential candidates, even those who aren’t actively job hunting. They spend their time digging through candidate platforms and industry-specific communities to find those candidates. But that’s not all; today’s talent sourcers are also leveraging AI talent sourcing tools to streamline their search.
According to HireEZ, “59% of HR decision-makers plan to invest more in AI in 2024”.
Once they’ve built a pool of potential candidates, they hand it off to the recruiter, who takes care of the interview process and final stages of hiring. Sourcers focus on identifying and engaging the right candidates, making sure your company has a steady flow of talent.
While both talent sourcers and recruiters play crucial roles in the hiring process, they’re responsible for different stages. The talent sourcer is focused on the initial stage which involves finding and attracting candidates. Their mission is to build a pipeline of qualified candidates by searching across the best candidate sourcing platforms to identify both active and passive candidates. They focus on outreach, engagement, and early candidate assessment.
On the other hand, the recruiter takes over once the sourcer has done the legwork of finding those candidates. Recruiters manage the rest of the hiring process—conducting interviews, evaluating cultural fit, negotiating offers, and ensuring a smooth onboarding process. They’re the ones building relationships with candidates and guiding them through to the final offer.
To put it simply:
While they work together, talent sourcers are all about finding the right talent, while recruiters focus on securing that talent for your team. In some companies, recruiters may handle both roles, but as hiring needs grow more complex, separating these functions can help ensure a smoother, faster process, especially when using advanced AI-driven sourcing methods.
Here’s a Youtube video by Outsource Accelerator that I found that talks about the key differences between both a Talent Sourcer and Recruiter.
As more companies feel the pressure of filling specialized roles, the demand for talent sourcers is growing. Hiring a dedicated talent sourcer can give your recruitment process a much-needed boost, especially when you’re looking to build a strong candidate pipeline in competitive markets. But before jumping into the decision, it’s essential to weigh the advantages and potential downsides.
In this section, we’ll explore the 5 pros and cons of hiring a talent sourcer in 2024, so you can make an informed decision about whether this role is right for your team.
When it comes to sourcing candidates, a talent sourcer opens up your options—big time. A talent sourcer digs deep into networks like LinkedIn, GitHub, and even niche platforms to find the people who could be the perfect fit for your company—even if they’re not applying directly. It’s all about getting ahead of the competition by reaching talent before they hit the job market.
Let’s face it: recruiters are juggling a lot. Between interviewing, negotiating offers, and handling onboarding, their plates are full. By bringing in a talent sourcer to handle the time-consuming task of identifying and reaching out to candidates, you let your recruiters focus on the more high-impact parts of the process.
Finding someone with the right skills is one thing, but finding someone who’s also a great cultural fit? That’s a whole different challenge. Talent sourcers have the expertise to do both, and that makes a big impact. In fact, companies with strong talent acquisition strategies are 33% more likely to outperform their competitors, according to Eurobrussels. So, by focusing on getting top-tier candidates in the pipeline from the start, a sourcer helps ensure that every hire is a win.
Time is everything when it comes to hiring. The longer it takes, the more likely you’ll lose top candidates to faster-moving competitors. That’s where a talent sourcer can really step up. LinkedIn reports that companies with proactive recruiting strategies reduce their time-to-hire by 20%. Why? Because sourcers are always building talent pipelines—so when a role opens up, recruiters aren’t starting from scratch. They already have a pool of pre-vetted candidates to tap into, speeding things up.
One of the best things about having a talent sourcer on board is that they’re not just thinking about today’s roles—they’re always looking ahead. By continuously engaging with potential candidates, even when there’s no immediate opening, they help you build a strong pipeline for the future. It’s all about being ready for whatever hiring challenges lie ahead.
Hiring a talent sourcer adds extra expenses to your recruitment budget, and that can be a significant consideration—especially for smaller businesses. For companies hiring only a few roles at a time, the cost of a talent sourcer may not always be justified compared to the potential return on investment.
One potential downside of hiring a sourcer is the overlap in responsibilities with recruiters. If the roles aren’t clearly defined, it can lead to confusion and inefficiencies within your hiring team. Without clear lines between sourcing and recruiting tasks, it can become harder to maintain an efficient and streamlined hiring process.
Talent sourcers focus primarily on finding and engaging candidates early in the process but often don’t carry that relationship all the way through. This can lead to a lack of personal connection between the candidate and the company, especially when compared to recruiters who manage the entire journey. According to Vorecol, personalized communication boosts candidate satisfaction rates by over 43%. If sourcers hand off too early, candidates may not feel as engaged, potentially impacting the overall candidate experience.
Not every company or industry needs a dedicated talent sourcer. For smaller businesses with limited hiring needs, or industries that rely on networking and referrals, a full-time sourcer might not be the most effective use of resources. In fact, research shows that small businesses prefer to use traditional recruiting methods, such as networking, because it’s more cost-effective for their limited hiring needs.
To really see the benefits of a talent sourcer, they need to be well-integrated into your recruitment process, which requires strong communication and management. According to a report from McKinsey, 44% of organizations report inefficiencies when new roles aren’t clearly aligned with existing processes. Poor integration between sourcers and recruiters can lead to miscommunication, duplicate efforts, and ultimately, longer hiring times. Proper management and a clear structure are essential to get the most out of a talent sourcer.
Hiring a talent sourcer can be life changing for your company, but it’s not always the right move for every company or every situation. So, how do you know when to bring one on board? Here are three scenarios where hiring a talent sourcer can make a big impact:
If your company is consistently hiring for multiple roles or growing quickly, a talent sourcer can be invaluable. When you’re trying to fill dozens or even hundreds of positions, recruiters often get bogged down with tasks like interviews, reference checks, and offer negotiations.
A talent sourcer can take the load off by focusing solely on building a steady pipeline of qualified candidates, allowing recruiters to focus on closing deals and onboarding.
Let’s face it, not every position is easy to fill. Specialized roles, especially in fields like tech, engineering, and healthcare, can sit open for months due to a limited talent pool.
A talent sourcer’s job is to proactively seek out candidates with these niche skills, whether they’re actively job hunting or not. If you’re struggling to find candidates with specialized expertise, a sourcer can help by diving deep into passive talent pools and industry-specific platforms to uncover the right people.
If your company is thinking beyond immediate hires and looking to develop a long-term talent pipeline, a talent sourcer is an excellent investment.
Rather than just filling positions as they open, a sourcer helps you stay ahead of the game by continuously building relationships with potential candidates, even when there isn’t an open role. This ensures that when a critical position becomes available, you already have a pool of engaged candidates to draw from.
Hiring a talent sourcer makes sense if your company is focused on consistently filling specialized roles or needs to build a long-term pipeline of qualified candidates. A sourcer can efficiently find and engage passive candidates, significantly reducing time-to-hire and improving candidate quality. However, if your hiring needs are limited, the extra cost and potential role overlap with recruiters may outweigh the benefits.
If you're looking to optimize your sourcing process when hiring a talent sourcer, tools like Tapflow can automate key sourcing tasks, providing a fast, scalable way to access top candidates efficiently.
Here’s how Tapflow can benefit a talent sourcer:
Sign up for Tapflow and start building your talent pipeline faster and smarter than ever before.
.svg)